Our Story!

There’s a certain, unmistakable familiarity you’ll feel the moment you arrive at the Fisherman’s Café. And whether you’re a native conch or you’re just stopping by for a visit, you’ll experience a noticeable sense of nostalgia, a feeling that perhaps you’ve been here before.

Each item on our menu is reminiscent of an era gone by — a time when local fishermen brought their day’s catch

right off their boats at the Historic Seaport and into the kitchen, and when chefs used only fresh ingredients to prepare handmade specialties.

Here, you’ll relish the flavors of Old Key West, as you indulge in classics like Harvey’s Johnny Cake smothered in cheese grits, peel and eat pink shrimp and our flavorful steak and egg sandwich. You’ll savor timeless favorites with a modern twist, including Lobster Enchilau Tacos with authentic island sauce and

our Black Bean Burger topped with avocado.

But no matter which items on our menu become your favorite, you’ll taste the quality of our wholesome ingredients, the richness of our fresh ground coffee and the succulence of our just-caught fish, shrimp, lobster and conch — each one paying homage to a simpler time, a slower pace and an authentic island experience in Old Town Key West.

Today's Specials

Sesame Guava Toast – $2.50
Guava and cream cheese on pressed Cuban bread with Sesame seeds
Blackened Shrimp Club Wrap – $11.95
Served with lettuce, tomato, bacon, avocado and mayo
Triple Decker Turkey Club – $9.95
1/2 lb of Smoked Turkey, Thick Cut Bacon, Greens, Tomato, Mayo, 3 Slices of Sourdough
Bacon Cheeseburger* – $9.95
Triple Blend Black Angus Beef Burger, Country Smoked Bacon, White Cheddar Cheese
Conch Sandwich* – $11.95
Served with lettuce, tomato, key lime tar-tar on Kaiser burger bun
“El Cubano” Breakfast Sandwich – $7.95
Farmhouse Organic Egg, Chorizo, Espresso Smothered Pork Shoulder, Swiss Cheese
Hill’s Cheese & Grits – $3.95
Add Bacon - 1.00 Add Steak, Lobster or Shrimp* - 2.00
Black Bean Veggie Burger – $8.95
Avocado, Caramelized Onions, Brioche Bun
Hogfish Sandwich* – $12.95
The Finest Local Fresh Catch, Caramelized Onion, Avocado, Sauce Remoulade

Locally Sourced

At Fisherman’s Café, we’re committed to using only the freshest, locally sourced ingredients in all of our menu items. From the just-caught fish, shrimp and conch that comes directly off the boats in the Key West harbor and the handpicked produce from Florida farms, to our own homegrown peppers and spices—the integrity of our ingredients provides an extraordinary level of flavor and freshness to all of our dishes.